I’ve always had a soft spot for watches. Not the luxury kind locked in glass cases, but the ones you can actually live in — commute, grab coffee, run errands, and still feel put together. Living in New York taught me that time moves fast, but style doesn’t have to be expensive to keep up.
Over the years, I’ve tried everything from $30 beaters to midrange automatics. What I’ve learned is that “affordable” doesn’t mean disposable. A good watch feels right on the wrist, tells a clear story, and doesn’t scream for attention. In this review, I’m sharing the watches that I actually wear — the ones that fit my daily rhythm in the city and don’t cost a fortune.
⌚ First Impressions
When I started collecting, my goal was simple: find watches that look good, feel solid, and don’t break $200. The hunt became a small obsession. I compared quartz and automatic movements, swapped NATO straps, and tested how they held up against city life — humidity, subway rush, and all.
A few names kept coming back: Casio, Timex, and Seiko. Each brand has its own personality. Casio is practical and rugged; Timex leans casual and vintage; Seiko feels timeless and quietly confident.
🏙 Real-World Use in New York
I rotate between a few favorites depending on the day. During busy weekdays, I usually grab my Casio F91W. It’s light, durable, and perfectly retro — the kind of watch that disappears on your wrist until you need it. I’ve worn it in the rain, at the gym, even during weekend bike rides along the Hudson. It’s still ticking after three years.

When I want something dressier, I switch to the Timex Weekender Chronograph. The ticking is loud — you’ll hear it in quiet cafés — but it has character. Paired with a leather strap, it looks way more expensive than it is.
For slightly more serious occasions, I wear my Seiko 5 Automatic. There’s something satisfying about seeing the second hand sweep instead of tick. It’s mechanical poetry — no battery, just gears, balance, and time itself.
⚙️ Performance & Key Features
Here’s how these watches hold up beyond looks:
- Casio F91W: Digital precision, alarm, stopwatch, and an LED backlight that somehow still feels cool from the 1980s. Battery life is legendary — up to seven years.
- Timex Weekender Chronograph: Analog layout, quartz movement, Indiglo night light, and interchangeable straps. The case feels sturdy for its price range.
- Seiko 5 Automatic: True mechanical movement with automatic winding, day-date window, 30–40 hours of power reserve, and stainless-steel case. It’s the kind of watch you can keep for decades.
Each of these performs differently but shares one trait: dependability. You can set them once and forget them, or wear them daily without fear of scratches and battery panic.
✅ Pros & ❌ Cons
Casio F91W
✅ Ultra-light and waterproof enough for daily use
✅ Extremely affordable (around $20)
❌ Plastic case can feel cheap
❌ No real depth for dressier outfits
Timex Weekender Chronograph
✅ Classic design with vintage appeal
✅ Easy to find replacement straps
❌ Loud ticking sound
❌ Battery tends to run out faster than expected
Seiko 5 Automatic
✅ True mechanical movement at an entry-level price
✅ Feels premium on wrist
❌ Slightly thicker and heavier
❌ Needs occasional resetting if left unworn
💸 Value for Money
If you’re building a small collection, these three form a perfect trio: casual, dressy, and classic. Together, they cost less than a single mid-tier fashion watch, yet each one offers a unique story and function.
Casio gives you simplicity and nostalgia. Timex brings personality. Seiko offers craftsmanship. None of them try too hard, and that’s exactly what makes them timeless.
I’ve worn them to meetings, airports, and dinner parties — and not once did anyone ask, “Is that expensive?” Instead, they asked, “Where’d you get that?”
🔄 Alternatives & Comparisons
If you’re exploring beyond these brands:
- Citizen Eco-Drive watches are powered by light — no battery changes, ever.
- Orient Bambino gives Seiko 5 vibes but leans more elegant and dress-watch oriented.
- Swatch Originals are playful, modern, and perfect for a splash of color.
These all stay under $300 and hold their own against pricier names.
🧭 My Verdict
Affordable watches aren’t just about saving money — they’re about finding pieces that match your pace. In a city where every minute counts, I need watches that are reliable, easy to wear, and quietly stylish.
If I had to pick one, I’d keep the Seiko 5. It feels like owning a piece of history without the price tag. The Casio F91W stays my everyday hero, and the Timex Weekender reminds me that timekeeping can have character.
Good watches don’t just tell time — they tell who you are when no one’s looking.
Written and tested by Chi Tran for 123Review.net.
Affiliate links may earn a commission, but opinions are my own.
Chi Tran is a tech and lifestyle reviewer based in New York City, exploring how simple tools make urban life smarter.