Living in New York means living with noise. Sirens, subway brakes, espresso machines — the soundtrack of the city is relentless. I’ve gone through enough pairs of headphones to know that true silence here is a luxury, not a feature. So when I got my hands on both the AirPods Pro (2nd Gen) and the Bose QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds, I decided to test them the only way that makes sense: through my actual days — from morning commutes on the F train to late-night walks through Midtown.
This review isn’t about specs in isolation. It’s about which one really works for NYC life — how they sound, feel, and perform when the city refuses to quiet down.
First Impressions
The AirPods Pro look familiar: small, white, minimal. They slip in your pocket easily, and Apple’s packaging always feels like opening a tiny design exhibition. The Bose QC Ultra, on the other hand, are bulkier — more serious, more “audiophile.” Their case is wider, and the matte finish feels premium but less convenient in jeans.
Pairing both was effortless. AirPods immediately sync with my iPhone and MacBook, while Bose requires the Bose Music app — not a big deal, but an extra step. At first touch, Bose felt sturdier; AirPods felt sleeker.
Still, first impressions can deceive. NYC demands endurance, not just elegance.
Real-World Use in the City
Let’s start with the subway test — the ultimate torture chamber for active noise cancellation (ANC). The Bose QC Ultra handled it like a pro boxer ducking punches. The roar of the train softened into a low murmur, and I could hear my podcast host as clearly as if he were sitting beside me.
The AirPods Pro performed impressively too — especially after Apple’s 2023 firmware update. They cut noise well, but not quite as deeply as Bose. The low-frequency rumbles of the train still crept in a bit.
Walking in the streets, I appreciated the AirPods Pro’s Transparency Mode more — it’s more natural, making it easier to cross streets safely or order coffee without taking an earbud out. Bose’s aware mode felt a little artificial, with a faint electronic hiss when the city got loud.
Calls were another story. The AirPods Pro won this round easily. My voice sounded clear to friends and coworkers, even near construction sites. Bose did fine indoors, but outdoors, wind often overpowered it.
Sound Quality & Listening Experience
Here’s where Bose flexes. The QC Ultra sound is rich, warm, and detailed — especially when you turn on Immersive Audio, their spatial sound mode. It widens the stage so even familiar songs feel new again. Jazz, acoustic, film scores — they all breathe through Bose.
The AirPods Pro lean more balanced. The bass isn’t as deep, but clarity wins. Vocals sound crisp, instruments well-separated, and the Adaptive EQ adjusts quickly when you move around. In a quiet café, they sound pristine.
If your playlists live in Apple Music with Dolby Atmos tracks, AirPods get a leg up. But if you want cinematic sound with weight, Bose still rules the earbud throne.
Comfort & Fit
After two hours of wearing both on a rainy Manhattan afternoon, I could tell the difference. AirPods Pro feel lighter and more secure. Their shorter stems and flexible tips mean they stay put even when I jog for a train.
The Bose QC Ultra have a more “sealed” feel — their stability bands keep them locked in, but they can feel a bit heavy over time. Not uncomfortable exactly, but noticeable.
For long work sessions or reading in a park, I reached for AirPods. For immersive music on a plane, Bose felt unbeatable.
Battery Life & Charging
Bose wins slightly here. You get about 6 hours per charge (8 without Immersive Audio) and 24 hours total with the case. The AirPods Pro last around 5–6 hours with ANC and 24 hours total with the case.
However, AirPods support MagSafe and wireless charging, which fits perfectly into Apple’s ecosystem — drop them on my desk charger, done. Bose uses USB-C only, which feels more universal but less convenient if you’re deep in Apple land.
Pros & Cons
✅ AirPods Pro (2nd Gen):
- Excellent transparency mode for city use
- Seamless Apple ecosystem pairing
- Compact, comfortable design
- Clearer call quality
- Wireless charging with MagSafe
❌ AirPods Pro (2nd Gen):
- Slightly weaker ANC than Bose
- Battery life could be longer
- White case shows wear easily
✅ Bose QC Ultra:
- Best-in-class noise cancellation
- Rich, powerful sound with Immersive Audio
- Secure fit, ideal for flights or long commutes
- Slightly longer battery life
❌ Bose QC Ultra:
- Bulky case and earbuds
- Calls less clear outdoors
- No wireless charging
Value for Money
Price-wise, they’re both premium. AirPods Pro hover around $249, while Bose QC Ultra can reach $299. For Apple users, that $50 difference buys more than hardware — it buys integration. If your life runs on iPhone, iPad, or Mac, AirPods Pro feel almost invisible in how they sync and switch.
But if your priority is sound — if you love the physical presence of music, the feel of bass in your jaw — the Bose QC Ultra justify their higher price. They turn New York’s chaos into a private concert hall.
Alternatives Worth Considering
If both feel too pricey, check out the Sony WF-1000XM5 — a kind of middle ground with excellent ANC and sound that rivals Bose. They’re smaller, lighter, and more Android-friendly.
My Verdict
After weeks of testing in Manhattan’s subways, coffee shops, and Central Park, here’s the truth: AirPods Pro win for everyday city life; Bose QC Ultra win for pure sound isolation.
I reach for AirPods Pro when I’m working, walking, or talking. They feel like part of the Apple rhythm — smooth, light, dependable. I grab the Bose when I want to disappear — when I want to escape the traffic hum and get lost in sound.
If you’re living in a city that never shuts up, you might need both: one for the noise of life, one for the music inside it.
Written and tested by Chi Tran for 123Review.net.
Affiliate links may earn a commission, but opinions are my own.
